The Denial and Its Cost
- Reflections on Nanking Massacre 70 years ago and beyond
Lillis Taylor
Graduate student China Studies
University of Washington
Seattle, Washington, USA
I
am a twenty-seven year old white female from Birmingham, Alabama. I
grew up in a town full of ghosts. The civil rights movement shaped
lives all across Alabama and often the nucleus of the battle was
centered in Birmingham. Lives were brutally battered and destroyed.
There was no regard for sex or age. And yet, with time, the battle was
won. That battle was before my time. Often, my mother thinks the battle
was before her time as well. She was an elementary school student
during the 60’s, and her middle-class, church-going family kept
her sheltered and out of the fray. During my formative years, I went to
school and played with black boys and girls. I thought nothing of it
and wasn’t aware of my hometown’s important social history
until I encountered lingering racism in the news or, occasionally on
the streets. My parents taught me the difference between right and
wrong and how absurd it is to judge people based on physical
differences. When I first learned and later read about slavery, the
Underground Railroad and brave freedom fighters such as Harriet Tubman,
Sojourner Truth, Frederick Douglas and educators such as George
Washington Carver, I was mystified by the crazed actions of one race
against another, but I was lifted up by their brave stories. This was
my first taste of the world’s imbalance.
When
I was nine years old, I went to visit my father in Northern Japan where
he was teaching English and trying to write the next great American
novel. After a month of exploring the wonders of rural Japan, hiking
among pristine streams and waterfalls, traipsing about in rice paddies
and plucking rosy apples from branches hanging with ripe fruit, my
father asked me if I wanted to spend a year in a Japanese school among
Japanese children. My summer had been magical and I was delighted at
the prolonged opportunity. Each day, I attended a fourth grade class.
My teacher, Sato Sensei spoke almost no English. During my year among
Japanese peers, I made many mistakes and grew deeper with understanding
from them. The experience of another culture instills compassion
because your eyes are open and only the emotionally blind are incapable
of compassion. My year in Japan was a rich, colorful year and it shaped
my sense of wonder and excitement. I learned to listen carefully, to
perceive and to be patient. I fell in love with Japan. I fell in love
with the resolve of the people. I fell in love with the sense of duty,
honor and calm that I felt from every soul I met.
After
my fourth grade year, I returned to Alabama with a devotion to Japan
rooted in my whole being. I grew up and moved to Seattle to pursue a
degree in Industrial Design. After graduation, I started working for a
company with manufacturing ties in Shenzhen, China. And thus, a new
devotion started to evolve. This devotion sprang from a different soft
spot in my heart. My love for Japan grew from the beauty and the
culture I had experienced at a tender age. My love for China grew from
an idea that there was a grave imbalance. I watched as my white-collar
co-workers experienced one world within the comfortable realm of
product design and as my blue-collar counterparts in China slaved under
very different conditions in order to produce the ultimately useless
items that we designed for Americans to purchase for amusement. I felt
that, somehow, my Chinese counterparts were being wronged. In every
facet of life, culture was telling me that China was a simmering pot of
opportunity, wealth and power. It seemed the time to make a change, and
so, I quit my job and left for a yearlong teaching contract in Wuhan,
Hubei Province.
That was exactly one year ago today, June 23rd
2006. A year ago, I didn’t know of the Nanking Massacre and I had
never heard of Iris Chang. I regret that it took so long to learn of
the tragedy that occurred at the hands of the Japanese, but I am
thankful to have the opportunity to write about it now. Because I love
Japan so, it is extremely important to me that the wrongs of the past
be recognized and atoned for.
In
my mind, it is no accident that the Holocaust inflicted by Nazi Germany
on the Jewish population of Europe during World War II is the first
genocide that school children in America learn of. Based on what I have
read about the Rape of Nanking, the atrocities occurred during the
second Sino-Japanese war, which was fought in tandem with the Second
World War. And thus the Japanese were committing crimes against
humanity at the same time as the Nazis in Europe, if not earlier, and
yet, after the war, the results of the Tokyo tribunal were very
different from those of the tribunal in Nuremburg, Germany.
In
Germany, many of the Nazi generals and sympathizers were put to death
after court proceedings that were presided over by a multinational
panel. In Tokyo, the power in the courts was still on the side of the
Japanese. In order for justice to come, it is necessary for China to
stand united against this terrifying history and speak up. The Chinese
government must do its part as a strengthening world power to request
honest telling of history and Japan’s role in it. Although the
truth of the Massacre was obscured by many of the Japanese participants
after the war, China’s government, led by Mao Zedong, further
hampered justice when it suppressed history in order to strike a
tenable diplomatic accord with Japan. Japan must risk likely shame and
accept with honesty and integrity the complete history of its
involvement in genocide during the second Sino-Japanese War. From my
time spent in Japan, I know that society is imbued with a sense of
honor and duty and that in the best of times, these traits bring out a
great loyalty, but this loyalty can be disfiguring to the overall goal
of love of country if it is stubborn and held in higher regard than
compassion for fellow humans be they fellow countrymen or old foes. It
is often this loyalty for country that leads to great lapses in
judgment the world around. The greater good for humanity should be each
citizen of the world’s guiding principle.
China
must stand united and speak up about the painful scars left by the
Massacre. At the time, China was a victim, but the country is victim no
more. China has shown the world what she can do on her own. The people
are strong and there is a determination that has built a strong economy
and a self-sufficient infrastructure. In regards to past wrongs, to
take the stance of a victim would weaken China’s ability to bring
justice to those real and fallen victims of the Massacre. It is
important that brave souls like Harriet Tubman and Sojourner Truth
speak up. Iris Chang was a brave soul. She should not be the only one
to stand up and demand action from the Japanese. In her time, she asked
for recognition of the atrocities and recompense. Because of her
constant research and her lone voice in the storm, she lost huge pieces
of her soul, and we lost a shining example of bravery and strength.
The
compassionate people of the world need to work harder to bring such
atrocities as the Nanking Massacre to the rest of the world’s
attention because these acts against fellow man are devastating. They
continue to occur and each time, it is a more humiliating realization
that we let it happen again. Bosnians and Serbs. Rwanda’s Tutsis
and Hutus. Israelis and Palestinians. Sunnis and Shiites. Muslims and
non-Muslims in Darfur, Sudan. There is too much apathy and the
genocides continue as comfortable citizens in comfortable countries
concern themselves with blocking out the truth as it appears on the
nightly news and in newspapers and on the radio. Iris Chang raged
against the apathy for so long and so alone that she lost her strength
and herself.
Iris
Chang’s demise is an additional tragedy, piled on the imbalance
of the still-suppressed truth of Japan’s acts after the second
Sino-Japanese War. Enough blood has been shed. It is time for
compassion on all fronts. The world’s youth are tired of the
mistakes of our predecessors, especially those who hold office and busy
themselves in bureaucracy and neglect the task they were elected to
contend with: the righting of wrongs and the protection of victims of
genocide and hatred.
Imagine
a world where Asia is united. What a powerful image that creates. So
much of the world’s population resides in Asia and it is time
these people had a united voice. There is no way for Asia to truly
unite until Japan confesses the wrongs perpetrated by its powerful
during and before World War II. But there is also a roadblock if China
is not willing to come to the table ready for honesty. Victim and Foe
must relinquish these roles alike and work towards a relationship of
unity that does not rely on differences in order to create boundaries.
It is time for honesty, openness, strength, integrity and forgiveness.
It is time for individuals to really see each other when walking down
the street. It is time for compassion. It is time for balance. And it
will always be time for remembrance of the mistakes we’ve made so
that we never make them again.